The news broke yesterday that it was official: the NCAA Men’s and Women’s Basketball Tournament will be expanding from 68 teams to 76 teams. It is effective immediately, meaning the next March Madness we see, will feature 76 teams. Throughout this article, I will go over the pros, cons, and the consequences (not all negative) of this move to expand the tournament. But first, I will explain how the expansion will look, and who will play in the extra games.
To accommodate the extra 8 teams that will be making the tournament, there will now be twelve “play-in” games, up from the “First Four.” These games will be played over the course of Tuesday and Wednesday, six each day, in Dayton, Ohio, the previous host of the “First Four,” and another site to be determined. It has already been announced that the second site will likely be in the Western half of the United States to help with logistics and travel arrangements. The First Round of the tournament will begin, as it always has in recent history, on Thursday. The teams that will play in these games will be the twelve lowest-seeded automatic bids and the last twelve at-large bids. The play-ins featuring the last automatic bids will feature eight teams seeded 16, and four teams seeded 15. The play-ins featuring the the last at-large bids will feature eight teams seeded 12, and four teams seeded 11. That is the official format of the tournament moving forward. Before getting into everything that is wrong with this new format, I want to go over the benefits.
The obvious beneficiaries of this new format are the Power Conferences. They will undoubtedly be getting some, if not most, of the extra eight at-large spots into the tournament. Last year’s First Four Out were Auburn, Oklahoma, San Diego State, and Indiana. Three of the four teams were from Power Conferences, and San Diego State played in the National Championship game only four years ago in 2023. The true mid-major schools might be left out. With that said, there is one more positive to this change, and it’s probably not one that many will expect.
In my opinion, the low-major conferences will be the ones that actually benefit the most. The reason for this is the NCAA Tournament Unit System. This is the system for how conferences, not teams, are financially rewarded for their performance in the tournament. Here is how it works:
- Each conference is awarded 1 unit per team that makes the tournament, therefore each conference is guaranteed at least 1 unit per season.
- Teams earn additional units by playing in more tournament games. Each win in the tournament guarantees a team another unit. New for this past season, the National Champion receives an additional unit.
- A unit equates to roughly $350,000 per year paid out over six years
- Units are paid to the conferences, not the teams, and the conferences are allowed to distribute the money however they want
- Most conferences split the money evenly among all teams, including those that did not make the tournament.
The reason the expanded tournament will help low-major teams is because there are more attainable units available. For a low-major conferences such as the Northeast Conference, America East, and the Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference, if they do not play in the First Four, where they would play another low-major team, they would play against a 1-seed and likely lose, only earning their conference 1 unit. With the expansion to 68 teams, and the addition of six play-in games for the bottom 12 automatic bids, these small, and traditionally weak conferences will have the opportunity to earn an additional unit. A perfect example of this is Siena last tournament. Siena led #1 overall seed Duke for the majority of the game, before ultimately losing. Siena did not play in the First Four, but was a 16-seed. This meant that Siena’s conference, the Metro-Atlantic Athletic Conference (MAAC), only received one unit for the 2026 Tournament. In the new expanded tournament, Siena would have played a “play-in game” against another 16 seed, and if they played like they did against Duke, they would likely have won, earning the MAAC two units for the Tournament. Because there are now six play-in games for the lowest automatic bids, there are now six additional “attainable” units for low-major conferences. Attainable is in quotes because while it is possible for 15 and 16 seeds to win their first round games, history shows that it is extremely uncommon. Since the tournament expansion to 64 teams in 1985, 1 and 2-seeds are 307-13 in first round games, for a win percentage of 95.94%. While the mid-major conferences may not be pleased by this expansion, both the power conferences and the low-majors will see this as a good move.
Now on to the negatives of this new format. This was not something that fans were clamoring for. In a quote to ESPN, John Calipari said, “I don’t know why you mess with something that’s working.” Agreed. The only people calling for this were the SEC and the Big Ten. They argue that their conferences are so superior to everyone else, that it is not fair that some of their teams knock each other out from making the tournament. And while the SEC and the Big Ten are both inarguably strong conferences, neither has had many champions in recent history. Since the tournament expanded to 68 teams in 2011, the SEC and the Big Ten have only combined for three champions!1 This is despite the fact that they routinely have the most teams in the tournament. There are many fans out there who have said that this is nothing other than a way for the NCAA to make more money. The NCAA admitted they will earn a profit on this expansion. However, they argue that the extra revenue will be minimal, and that this is in the best interest of the sport.
The main issue that I have with the expansion is that it felt incredibly unnecessary. In my opinion, the biggest question I have is simply: “Why?” What is the point of adding eight more at-large teams? There was also no need to skip from 68 to 76 without first going to 72. This would have made much more sense, and would have made the bracket more aesthetically pleasing. There would be eight play-in games, four of them featuring the final eight automatic bids, and four of them featuring the final eight at-large bids. This would lead to play-ins for the 16-seeds and likely the 12-seeds.2 Instead, there are two extra play-ins for 15-seeds and two extra play-ins for 11-seeds.
One additional thing to consider is the impact this will have on bracket pools and games. Will the ESPN Tournament Challenge choose to exclude twelve games from their competition? If not, then users likely will have less than 48 hours to create and submit their brackets. While this may not be a big deal to most people, it is big deal to me. Previously, I have excluded the First Four games from calculating tournament results. However, moving forward, can I exclude twelve games? My initial reaction is no, and the reasoning is sample size. Now including the “play-in” games, my sample size grows from 63 games per year to 75. This might allow me to make more informed conclusions per year, and try to conclude which models are better than others.
Does the math support the move to include more at-large teams? Let’s look at the data. Since 2011, there have been 30 First Four at-large teams in the tournament (2 per year). Those 30 teams have won a combined 23 games, averaging less than a win per team. 13 of the 30 teams won their first round game, and 6 of the 30 won two games and made the Sweet Sixteen. 13 out of 30 winning their first round game is a win percentage of 43.33%, which is actually higher than the all-time 11-seed win percentage of 39.7%. Granted, the sample size is significantly smaller, but it is still important to note.
Going into this, I will fully expecting to write about how awful this expansion is, and how it is killing the game, but there are undeniable benefits for low-major conferences that have to be acknowledged. If I were Charlie Baker, President of the NCAA, I would have pushed for a redistribution of First Four games, rather than expansion. The best part of the expansion is the addition of more attainable units for low-major conferences. Rather than expanding the tournament by allowing eight more at-large teams, keep the tournament at 68, and make all First Four games for the eight lowest seeded teams in the tournament, regardless of automatic or at-large bid type.3 In this format, there would still be four play-in games, but they would all feature 16-seeds. This way, low-major conferences have the opportunity to earn more units and get much more television exposure. Unfortunately, it is incredibly unlikely that the NCAA will ever decided to shrink the tournament, so 76 will have to be the new normal, at least until they decide to expand to 80… or 96… or eventually 128 teams.
- 2026: Michigan / 2025: Florida / 2012: Kentucky ↩︎
- The seeding of the final eight at-large bids depends on the overall seeding of the automatic qualifiers. ↩︎
- It would always end up being the lowest eight automatic bids, due to weakness of the smaller conferences. The only way it would include an at-large team is if a lot of teams in weaker conferences were to put together undefeated, or close to it, seasons similar to what Miami (OH) did in this past season. ↩︎
Leave a Reply