This article is the second annual edition of finding out who the league’s most well-rounded player using the Five Tools of Baseball.
Note: All Statistics were gathered from Baseball Savant unless otherwise stated.
In last year’s article, I searched through all qualified position players to find the most well-rounded player using classic baseball scouts’ “five-tools.” Those are Hitting for Contact, Hitting for Power, Running, Fielding, and Throwing. Most major league players are really good at one or two of these, but usually not all of them. A good example of this is Taylor Walls, shortstop for the Tampa Bay Rays. Walls won the Gold Glove Award for American League shortstops, beating out Bobby Witt Jr. However, Walls was the worst qualified hitter in the major leagues in xwOBA1. While he is a very valuable fielder, he offers almost no value as a hitter. This is why baseball scouts and front offices are always searching for that Five-Tool Player. Last year’s winner of the award: MLB’s Most Well-Rounded Player, was Bobby Witt Jr. He edged out six other players who qualified for the finals by being above-average in all five tools.
In order to find the best five-tool player, I used Baseball Savant’s Percentile Rankings Leaderboard among other statistics. To be included in the Percentile Rankings, players must have 2.1 Plate Appearances per Team Game (340.2). There were 246 hitters that hit this criteria, and for the purposes of this article, those will be known as “qualified hitters” or “qualified players.” This leaderboard has each player’s advanced statistics ranked in order of percentiles, perfect for trying to find who ranks the highest in the categories needed for this article. A true five-tool player must be at least above average in all five areas. This means they must rank in the 50th Percentile or above for each tool. Each category will have its own criteria to eliminate players that are below average. Players that pass the criteria in all five categories will be added to the Final Five-Tool Player List. Once this list is compiled, players will receive points based on how they rank compared only to the other players on the list. The player with the most points after all five categories will be declared the Most Well Rounded Player of 2026.
Let’s jump right into it with Hitting for Contact. I used the same three statistics as last year in determining which players were above average at hitting for contact: Expected Batting Average (xBA), Whiff Rate (Whiff %), and Strikeout Rate (K%). In order to be considered above average at Hitting for Contact, a player must have an average percentile rank above 50 for the three statistics. In total, there were 121 players that ranked above average for the Hitting for Contact statistics. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the player that led the leaderboard in average percentile rank for the three Hitting for Contact statistics was Luis Arraez. If you read last year’s article, or read my article about the contact wonder that he is, this is definitely not a shock. What is surprising is some of the players that missed the 50th Percentile cutoff. Unanimous NL MVP, Pete Crow-Armstrong just narrowly missed out with an average percentile rank of 45. Finishing in the 22nd Percentile in K% really brought his average rank down. In total, there were ten players who finished above average in all of the other four tools except for Hitting for Contact. Those players are (ranked in order of how close they finished to the 50th Percentile in Hitting for Contact: Jackson Merrill, Pete Crow-Armstrong, Seiya Suzuki, Byron Buxton, Dylan Crews, Garrett Mitchell, Cam Smith, Heriberto Hernández, Jarren Duran, Colton Cowser. And finally, the worst player in the Hitting for Contact category in 2026 was Colson Montgomery, who set an MLB record for the most Single Season strikeouts.
Now on to Hitting for Power. As I did with Hitting for Contact, I used the same two statistics as last year: Expected Slugging Percentage (xSLUG) and Barrel Rate2 (Barrel %). These two statistics truly represent power because it isolates both how often a player is barrelling the baseball and what his expected number of bases per at-bat is. Players that hit the ball harder and farther will have a higher xSLUG, and players that have a higher Barrel % will hit the ball harder and further more often. The top hitter in this category in 2026 was a three-way tie between Yordan Alvarez, Shohei Ohtani, and James Wood. All of these players crush the ball, but will ultimately fall short of being MLB’s best Five-Tool Player in 2026 due to coming up short in other areas. In fact, none of those three hitters are above average in just three of the five tools. The worst qualified hitter in the Hitting for Power category in 2026 was a tie between speedsters Chandler Simpson and Nasim Nuñez. The players that were above average in all other four tools except for Hitting for Power are Drew Gilbert, Ceddanne Rafaela, Maikel Garcia, Nathan Church, Steven Kwan, Austin Martin, and Zach McKinstry. Most of these players are great fielding and speed guys, but obviously lack the power to get them to Five-Tool level. There were a few big surprises of players that missed out on being above average in Hitting for Power. I believe the most notable among them was Vladimir Guerrero Jr. While Vladdy was not going to win the Most Well-Rounded Player award, due to his low sprint speed, he would typically be a no-doubter to be above average in this category. Unfortunately for the Toronto Blue Jays, his power struggles were well-documented this season; he did not even have a home run in his home park in Toronto until September.
Next up is Running. This one is fairly straightforward, and it is measured by sprint speed percentile rank. While I could use stolen bases or baserunning run value in addition to sprint speed, I feel like just using sprint speed is a better way to determine the best Five-Tool player. This is because I am looking at it mostly from a scout’s perspective, and sprint speed is a nice, simple way to determine a player’s running ability. The fastest runner in the league this season was Henry Bolte, maybe the most appropriately named player in the league! The slowest qualified runners in the league were Salvador Perez and Josh Naylor3. There’s not much else to this category, but some notable names that missed out are Ronald Acuña Jr, Francisco Lindor, and Cody Bellinger. All three players have previous seasons with 30 or more stolen bases, and were ranked in the 70th percentile or higher in sprint speed at one point in the last 3 years. Surprisingly, there were no players that were above average in the other four tools outside of Running.
With that, we move on to Fielding. For this tool, I used two statistics: Fielding Run Value and Defensive Runs Save (Fielding Bible). For each of these statistics, I treated 0 as average, and thus any positive value resulted in being above average in that statistic. To qualify as an above average fielder, players must have positive values for both FRV and DRS. There are no best or worst fielders overall because we did not use a percentile leaderboard, but rather the raw values for both statistics. That being said, the best fielders for Fielding Run Value and Defensive Runs Saved were Pete Crow-Armstrong and Wilyer Abreu, respectively. The worst fielders for FRV and DRS were Logan O’Hoppe and Luke Keaschall. For this category, there were four players that were below average in Fielding, but above average in the other four tools: Fernando Tatis4, Casey Schmitt, Kody Clemens, and Julio Rodríguez. Both Tatis and Rodriguez made the finals last year, being above average in all five tools. Tatis finished 2nd behind Bobby Witt Jr, and Rodríguez finished in 3rd.
Finally, we have arrived at the last tool: Throwing. This is another category with a straightforward criteria: Arm Strength. This is calculated by taking the average speed of the top portion of a player’s throws. The number of throws that represent the “top portion” is different depending on position. For 1st Basemen, the top 1% of throws are averaged, for other infielders, the top 5% of throws are used, and for outfielders, it is the top 10% of throws. The player with the highest arm strength value was Jac Caglione with an average throw speed of 98.7 miles per hour. The player with the lowest arm strength value was Vinnie Pasquantino with an average throw speed of 66.3 miles per hour. There were two players that were below average in arm strength, but above average in the other four tools: Daylen Lile and JJ Wetherholt.
So using our criteria for each of the five tools, and eliminating any player that is below average in any of the five, we are left with just six players. In last year’s article, there were seven players that qualified for the finals. Those six players, listed alphabetically, are Andy Pages, Bobby Witt Jr, Carson Benge, Jackson Chourio, Michael Harris II, and Wilyer Abreu. Only two players were able to qualify both last year and this year: Witt and Harris. So now, I need to crown this year’s MLB’s Most Well-Rounded Player. To do this, I will rank each of the six players on each of the five tools. 1st Place will receive 6 points, 2nd Place will receive 5 points, and so forth. I will be using the same statistics and average percentile ranks for all categories except for Fielding. For Fielding, I will be using the sum of the Z-Scores for Defensive Runs Saved and Fielding Run Value. The Z-Scores will be calculated using only the players that had a positive value in both statistics. Without further ado, here are the results for the 2026 season:

Repeating as MLB’s Most Well-Rounded Player, Bobby Witt Jr takes down his competition by dominating the hitting and running categories. He finished above the 70th percentile in all four categories that used percentile leaderboards. A huge round of applause goes to Carson Benge for making the finals as a rookie. Finishing as the fifth most well-rounded player in the league this year, Benge deserved to win Rookie of the Year for the National League ahead of Sal Stewart in my opinion. I understand that Stewart hit over 30 home-runs and 100 RBI’s as a rookie but Benge excelled in every facet of the game, as evidenced by his qualification for the finals of MLB’s Most Well-Rounded Player. Finally, as I mentioned last year, it just goes to show how rare true five-tool players are. Only six players graded out as above average in all five categories for the season. It’s clear that Bobby Witt Jr is the definition of a Five-Tool Player, now winning the award in back-to-back years.
- Stands for Expected Weighted On-Base Average; a statcast stat that estimates a hitter’s expected success of their batted balls using launch angle and exit velocity. It is now being used as the most complete batting advanced statistic. ↩︎
- From Baseball Savant: To be Barreled, a batted ball requires an exit velocity of at least 98 mph. At that speed, balls struck with a launch angle between 26-30 degrees always garner Barreled classification. For every mph over 98, the range of launch angles expands. ↩︎
- This makes Josh Naylor’s back-to-back seasons with 30 stolen bases even more impressive! ↩︎
- Tatis was last year’s Platinum Glove Winner for the National League, making it very surprising he missed out on being simply above average this year. ↩︎
Featured Image: Steve DiMatteo (@stevedimatteo)

Leave a Reply